Lady lazarus bible story5/2/2024 So we are safe to conclude that Matthew and Mark are thinking of the same event. They mean the same thing, with only difference in detail. For instance, if (hypothetically speaking) four of the disciples objected, it is not wrong to say either that “the disciples” objected or that “some” objected. Quite frankly, this amounts to a difference only in detail of description, not of contradiction. The only difference is that Matthew says “the disciples” objected, while Mark says only “some” objected. Simply put, their accounts are almost identical to each other. The second thing we can deduce right away is that Matthew are Mark record the same event. His response, like the objections given, is completely different.įor these reasons we can see clearly that Luke records his own unique account. However, in Luke’s account, Jesus forgives the woman and tells a parable about the power of forgiveness. In the other three gospels, Jesus responds to the objections by stating that the poor can be helped any time, but he can only be anointed for his short time on earth. These are significantly different objections. In Luke’s account, the objection is that the woman who is touching Jesus is a dirty sinner. In the other three gospels, the primary objection from onlookers is that the expensive perfume used to anoint Jesus is wasted. Even though Matthew and Mark say their account happen in the home of Simon the leper, these are clearly two different individuals. Luke’s account takes place in the home of Simon the Pharisee. Luke’s anointing account happens very early in Jesus’s ministry, while the others all happen near the final week leading up to his death. This can be determined by observing several major differences from the other accounts. The first is that Luke’s gospel records a unique event that no other gospel contains. There are two things we can determine fairly easily. Analyzing the text closely reveals some important things. At other times, they are quite different. I believe Jesus was anointed twice, and that three of the gospels record the same account, with the other gospel (Luke) recording a separate incident.įirst, to help get a quick overview of the stories, I’ve created this chart to outline the basic elements of each story and how they compare to one another.Īs you can see, some elements compare very similarly with each other. I want to briefly present my own conclusion and how I came to it, which is in agreement with the ESV Study Bible. Naturally, others have come to different conclusions even from these. On the other hand, the ESV Study Bible notes conclude that Jesus was anointed only twice. For example, the popular website GotQuestions concludes that the gospels record three separate events. Some people get really freaked out when they learn that the gospels have some apparent contradictions, but many Christians have learned this fact and go forward with confidence in God’s Word and their faith intact.Īs I looked at some of the material on this particular story, it was clear that different authors have come to different conclusions about how many times Jesus was anointed in the gospels. Bible scholars have written massive volumes to address these issues on possible ways to harmonize the gospel accounts together. The gospel accounts of Jesus’s life differ from one another, and also have a lot of overlapping similarities. The first thing to say is, Don’t be alarmed. How many times was Jesus really anointed? Do these tell the same story? Or do they tell of multiple accounts? Did the authors get some information wrong? How can we reconcile these differences? Not all of the details are the same, and some even appear to contradict each other. The issue is that each account has some discrepancies in it. The four gospels all contain very similar accounts of Jesus being anointed by a woman while at a dinner party. In my study for this message, I came across a bit of a dilemma.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |